Welcome to Arthur's Pet Pantry


About Us

The Beginning

Arthur's Pet Pantry is a 501(c)3 nonprofit charity helping supplement feeding pets in need. The pantry was founded in 2011 by Cindy McEvoy and in 2014, when McEvoy stepped down, it was taken over by Abigail Erdley. It is currently being run by her mother Sue Straub, family and friends. Our mission is to provide supplemental pet food to people for their pets who might otherwise not to be able to afford it. And to help pets stay at home with their families instead of entering the shelter system.

Who was Arthur?

At one time an abandoned but personable cat showed up in Mifflinburg. Initially named Crippled, he became a neighborhood cat. He lived with a family for a while, but they moved, and he kept coming back to Mifflinburg where he stayed with an old guy who lived near the cemetery. When he died, Arthur came to his sale and to Christkindle. He went everywhere around town. He became such a town character that he was dubbed Sir Arthur and became known as the Cat Mayor of Mifflinburg.

Arthur passed away in 2011.

Cindy McEvoy asked her friends what could they do to help pets before they wind up in the shelter system? The answer was to help families having financial difficulties to feed their pets. So, in 2011 the pet food bank was born.

The mission continues to provide supplemental pet food to people for their pets who might otherwise not be able to afford it. And to help pets stay with their families and out of the shelter system.


 Distribution Locations and Times

Lewisburg is the 3rd Wednesday of every month at Mazeppa's Manna, 3200 Johnson Mill Road, from 10 am to noon. 

Northumberland is the 3rd Saturday of every month at the Trinity United Methodist Church, 300 Sixth Street. Photo ID and proof of living in the Shikellamy School District is required. From 9 am to 11.

Our Corporate Sponsors

Brookpark Pet Supply, Lewisburg

Thank you!

Food Donation Box L​ocations

Laurelton: West End Library

Lewisburg: The  Silvermoon flea market by the restaurant, BZ Motors, 

Mifflinburg: OIP, Tack Room, Inc., 

Milton: Tropicana Tan-A-Rama, YMCA , Rebecca  O '  Outlet, Arrowhead 

Montgomery  :  Coles coffee & consignment 

New Berlin: Creative Styles by Tiffany

Selinsgrove: Companion Animal Hospital, Sunbury Motors Kia

Sunbury: Sunbury Animal Hospital, Sunbury Market  House, Beiters

Watsontown: Rene's Barber Shop, Susquehanna Trail Animal Hospital, T k tackle

Northumberland:  W&L Subaru

Please Note: We will also take donations at Mazeppa's Manna the third Wednesday of the month from 10 am to noon. The address is, 3200 Johnson Mill Road, Lewisburg, Pa 17837.

Board of Directors and Membership

Executive Director: Susan Straub

Vice Director: Shawn Straub

Secretary: Melissa Rea

Treasurer: Susan Straub/Shawn Straub

Distribution Coordinator: Sue Straub

Social Media Director: Denise Lewis

Fundraising Co-Chairs: Liz Reigle, Michelle Ballou and Cathy Bellve


Sandy Milbrand, Bob Milbrand, Anne Russell, Marty Russell, Denise Lewis, Melissa Rea, Liz Reigle, Heidi Eck, Michelle Ballou, Megan Erdley, Evelyn Drumheller, Donna Culp, Greg Shaffer, Tammie Wendt, David Eck, Michael Culp, Cathy Bellve

Future Appearances/Projects

April 23,2022 8th Annual Bonehunt, Brown Avenue Park, Milton PA 17847 from noon to 4pm. There will be a bonehunt/ basket raffle/ vendors and food trucks! More info can be found on our Facebook page.


Contact Information

A 501(C)3 Non Profit

1020 Fonda Rd

Milton, Pa 17847


Facebook: Arthur's Pet Pantry

Instagram: Arthur's Pet Pantry


Get in Touch

Thanks for submitting!